Tuesday, February 3, 2015

Comparing Mixers for Precast Applications

There are a lot of concrete mixer out there in the market today for precasters to choose from. In my experience I have work closely with at least six distinct type of concrete, in passing with few other, from so many companies that it is beyond count. I have worked for three different companies that manufacture concrete mixers and worked for two other that sold concrete mixers as a part of Turn-Key projects (yes, that is five different employers...I know). Since I started in the concrete equipment industry 20 years ago I have learned quite abit about concrete mixer for a factory setting, and here is what (I think) I know:
 

Counter Current Mixers (Planetary Mixers):
This is the mixer that I mostly grew-up around Pedershaab (which was the first company I sold equipment for) often paired their plants with Skako and sometimes Haarup, both Danish companies making Planetary mixers. Masa and Wiggert both make planetary mixers, and are companies I sold equipment for. Mixer Systems here is the US, and my current employer, also produces a planetary mixer. I have more experience with these mixers than any other.

In a nutshell, the planetary has the design to be one of the fastest mixing mixers available. they are good and reliable mixers. in some applications they excel beyond the pan and horizontal shafts. Also, the ability to have multiple discharge door as on the pan, can be a huge advantage. However, which today's more complex mixes such as SCC and even a standard zero slump, the mixing speed advantage is reduced. As I grew up, I saw the planetary as a one-size-fits-all, be-all-end-all of mixers. Today I see the planetary as a very useful tool in a belt of very useful tools, it has it applications but there may be better options, depending on what needs to done.

Eirich R12 or Cyclone Mixer:
This is an exceptional mixer, especially for Face-Mix on pavers. When I was with Masa, who produces paver plants, they produced a version of this mixer, and I was amazed at its ability to use a single shaft with mixing tines, revolving at an exceptionally high speed to pulverize the materials. this was very important as face mix is often prone cement and color balls because of the fine materials used. This is what high-sheer really is. Price on a mixer of this sort is often the biggest issue, as they often run 2 -3 times the price of another style mixer in the same size. Additionally, this mixer design have only a single discharge door, though I believe with a bit more money equipment that can be overcome.
 

Horizontal Shaft Mixer (Paddle or Spiral Blade):
Slow and Steady Wins the Race! When I first started with Mixer Systems, I had a bias against this mixer. Now I think it is the best mixer ever made. OK… that may be a little much, but let me explain my enthusiasm on this.

At Mixer Systems we call this mixer the Praschaak. There are other producers with this same design concept including Besser and, I believe, Columbia. They are seen as old technology,  often eliciting jokes such as "This is how cavemen made concrete". Maybe it is true that the technology is old, Praschaak was making this mixer in the 1940's, I have seen many in my travels running daily that were produced in the 50's and 60's. So, yeah they are old. They are simple to. A single horizontal shaft with either paddles or blades mounted to it turning at a pedestrian revolution every 1.5 -2.5 seconds. The body I like a barrel on its side, and yet it's produces just about every kind of concrete on the market and does a good job of it time and again.

I have seen horizontal shat mixers used for producing concrete pavers on various block and paver machines, and making consistent concrete with consistent colors, 4-5 minute cycles. Indeed the US block industry developed using such mixers. However, the real magic of the horizontal shaft mixer is for the producers of SCC that pour with buckets, this mixer's door design allows for the least amount of drop from mixer to buckets and that saves on clean-up. Also, the difference in mixing times of the Horizontal shaft and mixers such as the planetary or twin shaft become far less noticeable, within seconds of each other, once a plasticizer and/or other admixes are properly mixed in. Good concrete takes time regardless of RPMs

Pan / Turbin:
The pan is an interesting mixer. It is unique among the other mixers listed here as it does not have an open body to mix in. Instead, the center of the mixers body is dedicated to the transmission while a trough is created between the inner and outer wall where the mixing takes place. I used to consider this mix a cheap alternative to the planetary, but that was an incorrect and unfair assumption on my part while there may be several applications in which the planetary is said to be superior, I have on numerous occasions seen pan mixers performing noticeably better. At Mixer Systems we produce Turbin/Pan mixers, as do companies such as Teka and Voeller.

I have seen pans running 90 second cycle time while feeding a concrete pump in a precast operation. I have spoken to Prestress producers running both Pan and Planetary Mixers side by side, who have told me that the Pan is far superior for zero slump concrete, and that the mixers run at nearly the same cycle. Indeed, Pan mixers have been a mainstay in the concrete pipe industry for years.

Because of the design of the mixer, pans will provide less volume by footprint than open body mixers. This also leads to additional wear where the concrete in focused. Pans often consume more wear parts than mixer such as the twin and horizontal shaft mixers. But they also offer additional versatility by allowing for multiple discharge doors

Ready Mix Truck:
I am not a ready mix expert. It is my understanding that mixing in a ready-mix truck requires up to 15% more cement than a batch mixer to get the same product strength. If I am wrong on this please correct me.

Ready mix is usually done in batches of 9-12 yards.





Twin-Shaft Mixer:
The twin shaft mixer is a truly fantastic mixer. It offers mixing times similar to the Planetary, durability similar to the horizontal shaft, and a very dynamic mixing action. It is usually is a pretty expensive mixer and if it is not…Beware! This mixer, unlike a horizontal shaft is designed to have the material being mixed over the height of the shaft. This means that the shaft seals are in constant contact with concrete. Not such a big deal for dry cast concrete, but a very big deal with wet-cast, and especially SCC. Those running concretes are as crafty as water when it comes to finding ways to escape, and standard shaft seals would last forever (and by forever I mean 6 months) for such a mix, an air-purge or similar seal is critical, and they are not free.

Another small and easily overcome drawback to the twin shaft is that there is a single discharge door and it is the length of the mixer usually. A chute is often needed to focus the flow of material.

No comments:

Post a Comment